Penelope Havana Bourbon Review | Rum Finished Bourbon That Breaks the Rules
Havana Bourbon
🥃 Penelope Havana Bourbon Review: Innovation or Identity Crisis?
What happens when you take a solid bourbon… and finish it in Caribbean rum barrels?
You get Penelope Havana Bourbon — one of the more unique bottles in the increasingly crowded world of finished bourbon.
And like most things in bourbon right now…
this one comes with a lot of opinions.
🎬 Watch the Full Episode
🥃 What Is Penelope Havana Bourbon?
Penelope Havana is part of the Penelope Cooper Series, a lineup focused on finished bourbons that push traditional boundaries.
Instead of sticking to standard oak aging, this release takes a blend of straight bourbon whiskey and finishes it in Caribbean rum casks, aiming to introduce sweeter, tropical notes into the final product.
On paper, it sounds great.
In reality… it can go one of two ways:
A perfectly balanced, dessert-like bourbon
Or something that barely resembles bourbon at all
👃 Nose (Aroma)
Right away, the rum finish makes itself known.
You’re getting:
Molasses and brown sugar
Light tropical fruit
Vanilla and caramel underneath
t’s sweet — noticeably sweet — but not completely out of control.
👅 Palate (Taste)
This is where things get interesting.
The sip brings:
Heavy sweetness up front
Brown sugar, caramel, and a hint of banana
Mid-palate spice trying to remind you it’s still bourbon
The real question becomes:
👉 Is this balance… or is this confusion?
🔥 Finish
The finish leans warm and slightly spiced, but the rum influence lingers longer than the traditional bourbon notes.
You’re left with a sweet, almost dessert-like aftertaste.
Which—depending on your palate—is either a win… or a problem.
⚖️ Rum Finished Bourbon: Does It Work?
Finished bourbons are everywhere right now:
Toasted barrels
Wine casks
Maple, honey, and everything in between
Rum finishing sits in a weird space.
It can:
Add complexity and sweetness
or
Completely overpower the base bourbon
Penelope Havana walks that line the entire time.
🧠 Tortured Bourbon Verdict
We don’t do hype. We don’t do marketing copy.
We pour it, we drink it, and we call it like it is.
Where does Penelope Havana land?
Is it a Cock of the Walk 🐓
A Hush Your Mouth 🤫
Or something that maybe wandered a little too far from bourbon?
👉 You’ll have to watch the episode to find out.
🥃 Final Thoughts
Penelope Havana Bourbon isn’t trying to be traditional.
And honestly—that’s the point.
If you’re a bourbon purist, this might not be your lane.
If you’re open to finished whiskey and a sweeter profile, this could be a fun bottle to explore.
Either way… it’s a conversation piece.
And in today’s bourbon world—that matters.
🔗 More from Tortured Bourbon
If you enjoy honest bourbon reviews without the hype:
👉 Visit us at TorturedBourbon.com
👉 Check out more bourbon reviews, comparisons, and blind tastings
👉 Join the community and see what we’re drinking next
