We tasted four bourbons ranging from roughly $25 to $200 without seeing the bottles. Could we identify the expensive whiskey—or would price prove absolutely useless?

Weller 12 vs Knob Creek 12 goes head-to-head in this controversial bourbon showdown. A wheated unicorn battles an oak-forward powerhouse as we break down flavor, value, availability, and which 12-year bourbon actually deserves your money.