Every bourbon fan has heard the phrase, “Every single barrel is different.” But how different can three bottles really be when they’re the same bourbon, the same proof, and come from the same distillery? In this episode of Tortured Bourbon, we put three Old Forester 100 Proof Single Barrel selections head-to-head to see if one barrel truly stands above the rest. From warehouse floors to flavor profiles, we’re finding out whether barrel location really matters—or if it’s all just bourbon folklore. 🥃

We taste Maker’s Mark’s 2024 Heart Release and 2025 Keepers Release—two unique Wood Finishing bourbons that prove why Kentucky still rules the bourbon world.

Big Horn Bourbon comes from the wide skies and wild spirit of Montana—but does this 80-proof whiskey from Willie’s Distillery deliver anything beyond frontier charm? In this Pour Decisions Wednesday episode, Heather and B explore this small-town bourbon and give it the full Tortured Bourbon treatment.

In this special episode, we review Four Walls Whiskey—created by the cast of It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia—as a tribute to bar culture and Rob McElhenney’s birthday. Blending Irish and American whiskey styles, this surprisingly smooth pour delivers flavor, heart, and a healthy dose of Philly chaos.